Amateur Photographer verdict

The S24 Ultra is an incredible all-round camera-phone, and amongst the best camera phones, and smartphones, out there, but it’s not perfect.
Pros
  • Improved image quality (slightly)
  • Massively improved screen (reduced reflection and improved scratch resistance)
  • Added AI features
  • Reflection removal particularly useful
Cons
  • Macro mode lags behind others
  • Shutter lag really hurts for fast moving subjects
  • 45W charging is looking slow

Replacing the S23 Ultra, the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is the flagship camera phone from Samsung, and adds a vast array of AI photography features, which is likely to make it one of the best phones for photography ever released! But how does it perform? Find out in our full review by expert Joshua Waller. 

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra cameras. Photo JW/AP

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra features: 

  • 200MP f/1.7 main camera, with OIS, 1/1.3inch, 23mm 
  • 12MP f/2.2 ultra-wide-angle camera (0.6x), 13mm 
  • 10MP f/2.4 3x telephoto camera, with OIS, 69mm 
  • 50MP f/3.4 5x telephoto camera, with OIS, 115mm 
  • – 5x telephoto camera has 10x Super AI / Multi-frame / Super Resolution 
  • 12MP f/2.2 PDAF selfie camera (same on all S24 models) 
  • 8K 30fps video, 4K 120/60/30fps 
  • 6.8inch screen, 1-120Hz, 2600nits, with Corning Gorilla Glass Armor* 
  • Titanium frame, 5000mAh battery 
  • Snapdragon 8 Gen 3 processor 
  • Available in Titanium gray, black, violet (blue-ish), and pale yellow
  • From $1299 / £1249 (256GB) 

How we test phones

We review smartphones from the perspective of choosing one for its photography and camera performance. We look at what the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra offers, and the features included for photography and video, paying particular attention to the cameras on the phone, photo editing capabilities, as well as the output from each different lens. 

Features, Hardware and Design 

When introducing the new S24 series Samsung were very keen to explain that we are now entering the “Era of AI” – with AI becoming a part of every new smartphone announced. In fact, it’s been in many phones for a while now, and subject detection AI has featured on Samsung phones for many years now.  

The new generation of AI, introduced with the S24 series (and coming to the S23 series soon), is being used for both photography when you take the photo, and when you edit the photos, with both on-phone AI technology (when shooting), and a mix of on-device and cloud-based AI features when editing.  

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra scene optimiser settings. Photo JW/AP

Similar features were introduced with the new Google Pixel 8 series, with Google’s Magic Editor, and photography features are now improved with an “AI ProVisual engine” which is said to improve night photography, noise performance, zoom quality, colour reproduction, as well as HDR (High Dynamic Range) imaging.  

HDR shooting has been improved and this SuperHDR feature now includes HDR preview so you can see what it’ll look like before you take the photo. There’s also support for HDR shooting in third party apps like Instagram, and Snapchat, as well as an improved HDR gallery.  

One AI feature that particularly stands out as useful for photographers is the new “Reflection removal (AI)” feature – this looks particularly useful if reflections from glass (etc) have been an issue in your photos.  

Before and after reflection removal on the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra (5x telephoto camera used)

Other on-device AI photo editing features include Portrait effect, Background blur, and Remaster photo. The options available will differ depending on what the phone detects and thinks will be useful editing options. You can also select an object directly in the Gallery, and create a sticker of the object.

In-cloud AI based features include removing, moving, and resizing objects (just like Google’s Magic Editor), as well as generative fill, for example if you want to rotate an image, it can then fill in the missing bits.  

Samsung say that the meta data will include whether AI features have been used in editing, to ensure that there is clarity and transparency around these features. A watermark will also be added to the image, that can’t be removed with Samsung’s own AI tools.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra cameras – here you can see the periscope lens for the 5x telephoto camera. Photo JW/AP

The new 50MP 5x telephoto camera replaces the 10x telephoto camera on the S22/S23 ultra 

The S24 Ultra uses the 50MP 5x telephoto camera along with AI tools to improve the image quality when shooting at 10x telephoto zoom. The sensor used is not only a higher resolution than the 10MP sensor in the previous phone, but it’s also larger, which Samsung say will give improved low-light performance. 

AI can also be used to generate intermediate frames in video, for example, letting you create slow-motion footage from your videos, after you’ve recorded them. The phone can record 8K video at normal frame rates (up to 30fps), as well as 4K video at up to 120fps (as well as 60 and 30fps). 

Updated screen design

The S24 Ultra comes with *Corning Gorilla Glass Armor, which is said to have 4x stronger scratch protection, and reduces glare by 75%. Gorilla Glass Victus 2 is used on the back, and the frame is made from Titanium. The screen also offers a brightness of up to 2600nits, which is seriously bright, although not quite as bright as that offered by the OnePlus 12. 

The reduction in glare and reflections is really noticeable, and impressive, especially when you see this next to another phone. 

Samsung Galaxy S24 series comes with a 12MP selfie camera with AF. Photo JW/AP

The design may, at first glance, look remarkably like the S22 and S23 Ultra, but the screen, and back, are no longer curved, and this gives the phone a slightly more business-like appearance. The cameras also take up a bit more space on the back of the phone as well.  

Oh, and another thing, just like Google phones, the Samsung S24 series will be getting 7 years of updates. 

Camera App… 

The camera app is very similar to those seen on other Samsung phones, like the S22 and S23 series, and if you’ve kept your phone up to date, then you shouldn’t see much difference between the models, except for the new AI features, which should be coming to the S23 series in due course.  

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra photo mode. Photo JW/AP

One instantly visible change is that instead of just four default camera options (0.6, 1x, 3, 10) there is now five different camera options, with 0.6, 1x, 3, 5 and 10 being different cameras you can choose from. 

The options available in the Portrait mode have been updated, so instead of just 1x and 3 (on the S22 Ultra), you now have 1, 2, 3 and 5x options available, giving a really extensive range of portrait lenses. You can adjust the blur as well as other options, including the backdrop, as well as using the night mode for night portraits. 

AI features aren’t just limited to photography though, with these also being available for search, translation, transcribing and more. 

AI Editing and AI Generative Fill

Using the generative fill to straighten an image, and expand the image, does a reasonable job if there isn’t much noteworthy in the edges of the frame, however, if there are houses or things with detail, then you can expect these to be smudged out. It’s a shame that the camera doesn’t simply use a second photo taken using the ultra-wide-angle camera to expand the photo when using the normal or telephoto cameras.

We also tried to remove the car in this image, only to have it replaced by a different AI generated car. Your results may vary, but for the most part, I didn’t find these very useful. Hopefully improvements will be made with future updates. 

Before editing, and after editing. The after shot shows a reduction in image quality, and at the edges the fill has been unsuccessful in filling in the detail. Trying to delete the grey car has resulted in the phone replacing it with a white AI generated car. An AI watermark has been added in the bottom left corner. (Main camera used)

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Performance

The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra gives bright, colourful images, with good levels of saturation. Exposure and dynamic range are very good, and the majority of the time you get consistent results without any focus issues. However, it’s when you start pushing the cameras to the limit that your image quality might drop. However, more on this later.

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra – ultra-wide-angle camera. Photo JW/AP
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/2.2 · 1/1192s · 2.2mm · ISO50

First we’ll look at the ultra-wide-angle camera on the S24 Ultra. The ultra-wide-angle camera is a 12MP f/2.2 camera (with 0.6x zoom), and gives a 13mm equivalent. Importantly, this camera features auto-focus, which means it can be used for close-up photos. The results from this camera are good, although, as with most ultra-wide-angle cameras, there is noticeable distortion towards the corner, and the image does get a little bit softer. Overall though, the results are really pleasing, with image quality only really dropping in low-light, or when taking close-up photos.

The main camera uses a 200MP sensor, with 16-in-1 pixel binning to give 12.5MP images. For many people leaving the camera on the default resolution is likely to be the best option, but if you want, you can also shoot at 50MP or 200MP. However, you’ll need to be prepared to have much larger, and therefore, slower to process images.  

I had to wait for the cat to stay relatively still in order to get a photo of this. The S24 Ultra often struggled to capture movement.
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/1.7 · 1/466s · 6.3mm · ISO12

The camera can struggle with moving subjects, and it seems like a missed opportunity that the camera’s AI technology doesn’t detect moving subjects and increase the shutter speed accordingly. I took a number of shots of animals, and missed a large number of shots due to the shutter speed being too slow.  

Low-light night shot with the main camera. Photo JW
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/1.7 · 1/33s · 6.3mm · ISO2500

Low-light photography – there’s an improvement here, with better results than the S22 Ultra, but the difference is quite subtle, and there’s a tendency for reds to be over-exposed. You can also use the 3x and 5x cameras for low-light photography, but noise is quite high.  

3X Telephoto Camera

3x telephoto shot.
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/2.4 · 1/659s · 7.9mm · ISO50

The 10MP f/2.4 3x telephoto camera gives a 69mm equivalent and is great for distant shots, with very good results in good lighting conditions. If you want to try and take photos of close-up subjects, such as cats, then unfortunately even in good light, the camera will decide to crop from the main camera, giving you a much lower quality image.  

Low light sunset, with the 3x telephoto camera on the S24 Ultra. Photo JW
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/2.4 · 1/33s · 7.9mm · ISO400

5x and 10x zoom compared… 

In good lighting conditions, the S22 Ultra’s 10x telephoto camera does provide a little bit more fine-detail, when compared to the 10x zoom on the S24 Ultra, but there’s really very little in it, unless you spend all your time pixel peeping on a computer screen.  

5x zoom photo. Photo JW
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/3.4 · 1/50s · 18.6mm · ISO400

However, in low-light conditions, the S24 Ultra does a significantly better job with it’s telephoto camera, but still isn’t as good as the main camera with it’s much larger sensor.  

10x zoom photo. Photo JW
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/3.4 · 1/169s · 18.6mm · ISO32

Ultimately most people are going to find having a 3x and a 5x zoom (along with a 10x) a better option than having to jump from 3x to 10x zoom (as on the S22/S23 Ultra).  

The 100x zoom option is best avoided, as you get a blurry mess. Perhaps if it’s a once in a lifetime opportunity to photograph the Lock Ness Monster, then fair enough, but otherwise, it’s not something to brag about.  

Moon photo taken at roughly 84x zoom. (All AI optimisations switched on)
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/3.4 · 1/929s · 18.6mm · ISO32

The less zoom you use, the better the result, but a Samsung S24 Ultra review wouldn’t be complete without an AI-assisted photo of the moon. This photo was taken at roughly 84x zoom. When the phone recognised the moon, a reasonable result was produced, but at other times this was a horrible mess. 

Macro shooting

This is where things can get a little bit frustrating. By default, if you point the camera at a close-up object you want to photograph, the phone will switch from the main camera to the ultra-wide-angle camera and give you a cropped (and distorted looking) photo, as well as lower quality results in low-light.  

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra – ultra-wide-angle camera. Photo JW
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/2.2 · 1/57s · 2.2mm · ISO100

Switch to the 3x camera, and the phone will crop from the 1x camera – giving a pixelated, but relatively pleasing looking, image.  

Switch to the 5x or 10x cameras, and the phone will again crop, this time from the 3x camera, giving a pixelated image. It’s quite frustrating, and it doesn’t advise you what’s going on until you look at the EXIF data after you’ve taken the shot. However, for the best results, the 5x option (which crops from the 3x camera) looks to give the best results. 

Switch to a phone like the iQOO 12, OnePlus Open and 12, Vivo X100 Pro, and some Xiaomi phones, and you can use the telephoto camera for some gorgeous looking close-ups – in fact all of the product shots in this review were taken with the Vivo X100 Pro’s 4.3x telephoto periscope camera. 

The 12MP selfie camera 

Like the S22, S23 series, the S24 Ultra has a 12MP f/2.2 selfie camera, with auto-focus. This will help with selfie’s and group portraits as the camera can focus on the correct area, rather than having fixed focus like many other phones. It’ll also give benefits to video recording and vlogging, with the camera being capable of 4K video recording.  

Selfie camera with background blur applied.
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/2.2 · 1/120s · 3.3mm · ISO40

I found results were pleasing, with good colours, good exposure, and reliable focus. Background blur can be applied when taking the photo, or afterwards in editing, and the results are very good, even with a lot of fine detail.  

Video recording

The 4K video mode gives you the choice of 60fps or 30fps. Results look very good, and you have the choice of switching between the different cameras, whilst filming, with 0.6, 1x, 3, 5 and 10x options available. If you use these on-screen options the zoom jumps quickly between the zooms, however you can also use your finger and slide smoothly from 0.6x all the way to 20x zoom, and this will give a really good amount of zoom, and a smooth looking video with fairly minimal “jump” between the cameras.

Value for Money

The obvious contenders in the flagship smartphone market are the Google Pixel 8 Pro, and iPhone 15 Pro Max, but with only 3 cameras on the back, do they really compete with the S24 Ultra? Well, if you want a 5x telephoto camera, and a 3x telephoto camera, then the S24 Ultra clearly wins.  

In terms of pricing, the S24 Ultra is priced at $1299 / £1249 (256GB), whereas the Google Pixel 8 Pro is cheaper, at $999 / £999 / £1059 (128/256GB) and the iPhone 15 Pro Max is slightly cheaper at $1199 / £1199 (256GB). 

Left to right: S24, S24 Plus and S24 Ultra. Photo JW/AP

If you go outside of these choices, the S23 Ultra can be found for much less, and will also be getting AI features as an update, and offers a 3x telephoto camera, along with a 10x telephoto camera. It’ll be interesting to see how this performs once it’s got the new AI features and updates. You can also save a lot of money by going for the S24, or S24 Plus, as long as you don’t mind the lack of a 5x telephoto camera.

Outside of Samsung, Apple, and Google, you have a range of choices, but availability in your area may be an issue. There’s the OnePlus 12 ($799 / £849, 256GB) which is widely available, and offers a 3x telephoto macro feature, but fixed focus selfie camera.

Outside of this, if available in your area, then the iQOO 12 ($700), and Xiaomi 13 Pro, are well worth looking at, as they all feature telephoto macro. There’s also the Vivo X100 Pro offering Zeiss branded cameras, a 1inch sensor, and a 4.3x telephoto camera as the zoom option, which can also be used for telephoto macro shots.  

However, you’ll have to look at these phones carefully to see if they all offer a selfie camera with AF, as this is not always found on all phones.  

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Verdict

The Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra makes some interesting updates, notably in style and design, and in terms of photography, there are improvements in the general image quality.  

Beyond this, the AI tools can help improve photos further (reflection reduction is particularly welcome), and there are now Google/Adobe style AI editing tools including moving objects, deleting objects, as well as generative fill, with mixed results.  

10x zoom photo. Photo JW
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/3.4 · 1/316s · 18.6mm · ISO32

One area where we’d like to see more photographic tools is in the shooting experience, for example, where are the slow-motion / long exposure shooting modes? These can be found on Google Pixel phones, and other competitors like Vivo, Xiaomi, etc. Being able to capture a creative waterfall shot is really impressive, and once you’ve used it, you’ll not want to go to a phone that doesn’t have this feature.  

The macro shooting experience and results could also be better, as we’re now seeing phones from OnePlus, Vivo (with the iQOO 12, and X100 Pro), Xiaomi, and others with really impressive telephoto macro capabilities that use the periscope camera, rather than just cropping from the ultra-wide-angle camera.  

Beyond this, there are other flagship phones out there with 1inch sensors. Samsung are incrementally improving the cameras and features available, but can’t really be seen as especially cutting edge when looking at the wider market.  

5x telephoto zoom. Traffic lights. Photo JW
Galaxy S24 Ultra · f/3.4 · 1/240s · 18.6mm · ISO40

For video recording, you can go up to 8K video, but probably of more use is the ability to record 4K at up to 120fps, as well as the ability to make existing video slow-motion, thanks to AI.  

One thing I’d really love to see is an improvement in shutter speeds, and shutter lag. There were multiple times where I missed the shot because the subject moved, due to shutter lag, or ended up with a blurred photo as the shutter speed wasn’t quick enough to freeze the motion. Perhaps this will be possible with a future update.  

However, saying all this, for those that simply want the best camera phone out there, from a mainstream brand, the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra is without doubt, one of the best camera phones currently available.  

Whilst there will be those brand-loyal to Apple, and therefore an iPhone is the best choice for them, for everyone else, the Samsung Galaxy S24 series will make an excellent choice.  

Sure, there are other phone brands out there, but often, the flagship models are only available in select markets, and until that changes, the S24 Ultra is the best Android phone you can buy right now. It offers more cameras than any other phone, and with a 3x and 5x telephoto camera, you can get a wider variety of shots. It’s also got an excellent 12MP selfie camera, with auto-focus, and 4K video recording, something that is still missing from some other flagships.  

Amateur Photographer Testbench Gold

Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra Specifications

Main camera200MP f/1.7 main camera, with OIS, 1/1.3inch, 23mm
Ultra-wide-angle camera12MP f/2.2 ultra-wide-angle camera (0.6x), 13mm 
Telephoto cameras10MP f/2.4 3x telephoto camera, with OIS, 69mm 
50MP f/3.4 5x telephoto camera, with OIS, 115mm 
– 5x telephoto camera has 10x Super AI / Multi-frame / Super Resolution
Selfie camera12MP f/2.2 PDAF selfie camera
Video 8K 30fps video, 4K 120/60/30fps 
Screen6.8inch, 1-120Hz, 2600nits, with Corning Gorilla Glass Armor
BatteryTitanium frame, 5000mAh battery 
Dimensions162.3 x 79 x 8.6 mm
Weight232g

*AI features are currently free, but till when? Hopefully the in-camera AI features will remain free.